Blog

What the Building Collapse in Gebze Tells Us: Making Hidden Risks Visible with Structural Health Monitoring

The October 2025 collapse of a residential building in Gebze shows how soil, design, changes in use and lack of inspection can combine into a slow-moving risk, and where structural health monitoring fits in.

November 16, 2025
City skyline with a residential building highlighted by sensor icons and vibration data, representing structural health monitoring

On 29 October 2025, the sudden collapse of a seven-storey residential building in the Gebze district of Kocaeli, Türkiye, shocked the country. A family of five was trapped; only their 18-year-old daughter was rescued alive from the rubble (Anadolu Agency).

This event is a painful reminder that buildings can pose critical risks not only during earthquakes but also in everyday life.

Subsequent investigations in the surrounding area revealed that many nearby buildings also showed serious structural problems. This points to a wider, systemic issue in the building stock, not a single building.

In this article we look at what can be learned from such incidents and where structural health monitoring (SHM) fits into the bigger picture.

1. Why do “healthy-looking” buildings collapse?

Preliminary assessments and expert comments on the Gebze collapse highlight risk factors that are familiar in many regions of Türkiye and beyond.

Ground movements and soil settlement

  • Buildings founded on variable soil may experience differential settlement over time.
  • Nearby works such as deep excavations, tunnels, metro lines or changes in groundwater level can weaken the soil supporting the structure.
  • Settlement can cause progressive damage, especially in corner columns and other critical load-bearing elements.

Soft-storey effects and commercial use at ground level

  • Ground floors used as shops, markets, cafés or restaurants often have fewer partition walls and larger open spans.
  • This can create a soft storey: the ground floor becomes much weaker and more flexible than the floors above.
  • In earthquakes and settlement scenarios, the soft storey tends to behave as the weakest link, making the whole building more vulnerable.

Previous use and thermal effects

  • In some buildings, the ground floor may previously have been used as a restaurant or another high-temperature environment.
  • Prolonged exposure to heat can degrade concrete, reduce the bond between reinforcement and concrete, and weaken columns and beams.
  • Even with limited visible signs, the structural capacity may already be reduced.

Ageing, poor maintenance and ignored warning signs

  • Cracks, excessive deflections, spalling at beam-column joints and doors or windows that begin to jam are often dismissed as “old building behaviour”.
  • In reality, these are indicators that should be followed throughout the service life of the structure.
  • When such symptoms are ignored, damage can accumulate over years until a relatively small trigger leads to a disproportionate collapse.
Even if a building has an approved design, permit and occupancy certificate, without monitoring soil conditions, changes in use and long-term behaviour we do not have up-to-date information about its real condition.

For an overview of soil–structure interaction and how it affects building performance, see the technical guidance published by NIST.

2. Where does structural health monitoring come in?

Structural health monitoring (SHM) measures how a structure actually behaves, using sensors and data analysis, continuously or at regular intervals, in order to detect damage and loss of performance as early as possible. SHM has developed significantly over the last two decades, with a large body of research on bridges, high-rise buildings and other critical infrastructure.

SHM is particularly relevant for structures exposed to:

  • Soil settlement and tilting (retaining walls, high-rise buildings, industrial facilities, structures next to deep excavations or tunnels)
  • Soft-storey configurations with commercial use at ground level
  • Older buildings that have already experienced earthquakes or heavy loading
  • Seismically isolated buildings and special engineering structures
  • Schools, hospitals and other buildings where failure would have severe consequences

Moving from a one-time, design-only mindset to monitoring through the whole life cycle turns unknowns into measured quantities.

3. How StructHEALTH uses SHM to address these risks

3.1 Vibration-based performance tracking (modal monitoring)

  • Accelerometers record the response of the structure, from which natural frequencies, mode shapes and damping ratios are identified continuously or at scheduled intervals.
  • A significant change in natural frequencies over time can indicate loss of stiffness, for example from cracking in load-bearing elements.
  • Comparing dynamic properties before and after earthquakes, or over several years, helps engineers distinguish normal ageing from changes that need investigation.

3.2 Monitoring soil–structure interaction

  • Tilt sensors at different corners of the building track long-term settlement, tilt and differential movement across the footprint.
  • This is especially important near metro lines, deep excavations, reclaimed land or areas with changing groundwater.
  • The effect of nearby construction on existing buildings is then quantified with measured data rather than assumptions.

3.3 Threshold-based automatic alerts

  • Limits can be defined for acceleration, tilt, frequency change, crack width and other parameters.
  • When a threshold is exceeded, site managers, facility operators or municipal authorities receive SMS, e-mail or platform notifications.
  • Stakeholders can then arrange inspection, preventive evacuation or strengthening in time.

3.4 Rapid post-earthquake assessment

  • After an earthquake, SHM records the accelerations, displacements and spectral demands the structure actually experienced.
  • These measurements can be compared with a numerical model of the building.
  • For owners responsible for many buildings, this supports data-driven prioritisation: which buildings to inspect first and where to send limited engineering resources. Final decisions on the condition of a building remain with the structural engineer.

4. Who benefits most?

  • Municipalities and public authorities: mapping risk in the existing building stock, identifying priority zones for retrofitting, and monitoring the effect of metro, tunnel and deep excavation projects on surrounding buildings.
  • Building and site managers: understanding how a building behaves under real loads and supporting periodic engineering inspections with measured data.
  • Industrial facilities: monitoring stacks, silos, tanks and critical production lines, and supporting business continuity decisions after earthquakes.
  • Education and healthcare buildings: following performance where life safety is paramount and supporting decisions on use after seismic events.

5. What does the Gebze incident tell us?

The Gebze collapse shows how soil conditions, design and detailing, changes in use and lack of maintenance and inspection can combine into a slow-moving but deadly risk, even without a major earthquake. Three messages emerge:

  1. One-time checks at the design and permit stage are not enough. Structures need to be assessed and monitored throughout their service life.
  2. Soil–structure interaction changes. Every new excavation, tunnel, fill or change in groundwater can alter how a building behaves.
  3. Data-driven decisions are no longer optional. In critical zones, structural health monitoring has become essential infrastructure.

Conclusion

We extend our deepest condolences to the families affected by the collapse in Gebze.

Soil investigations, periodic assessments, sensor-based structural health monitoring and digital models should become standard practice in our cities, whether for an apartment block, an industrial plant, a school or a hospital.

If we cannot answer the question “How does this building really behave?”, we cannot be sure about its safety.

Contact us to discuss structural health monitoring options for your building or project.